A natural form of sugar could offer a new, noninvasive way to precisely image tumors and potentially see whether cancer medication is effective, by means of a new imaging technology developed at UC San Francisco in collaboration with GE Healthcare.
The technology uses a compound called pyruvate, which is created when glucose breaks down in the body and which normally supplies energy to cells. In cancer, however, pyruvate is more frequently converted to a different compound, known as lactate.
Previous animal studies showed that scientists could track the levels of pyruvate as it is converted to lactate via magnetic resonance imaging (MRI), by using a technology called hyperpolarization and injecting the hyperpolarized pyruvate into the body. The amount of lactate produced and rate of conversion enabled researchers to precisely detect the limits of a mouse’s tumor, identify which cancers were most aggressive and track early biochemical changes as tumors responded to medication, long before physical changes occurred.
Now, a 31-patient study performed by scientists at UCSF and their collaborators at GE Healthcare has shown that the technology is safe in humans and effectively detects tumors in patients with prostate cancer.
Findings appeared online in the Aug. 14 issue of Science Translational Medicine.
Diagnosing Cancers Without Biopsies
While this first-in-human study was designed to identify a safe dosage and verify effectiveness, it lays the groundwork for using the technology to diagnose a variety of cancers and track treatment noninvasively, without conducting repeated biopsies.
Sarah J. Nelson, PhD
“We now have a safe dose for patients – that was our primary goal,” said Sarah J. Nelson, PhD, a UCSF professor of radiology and director of the Surbeck Laboratory of Advanced Imaging at UCSF, who was lead author on the study and led a diverse team on this project.
“In animal models, the amount of lactate over pyruvate is directly related to the aggressiveness of the cancer. We also have a lot of data that show it’s reduced in cancers after treatment,” she said. “This is a very ubiquitous molecule that will be important in tailoring treatments to specific individuals.”
Prostate cancer is the most common form of cancer, with more than 200,000 new cases reported each year in the United States, according to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. The increased use of prostate-specific antigen (PSA) levels for screening men has been widely recognized as having identified more patients with prostate cancer at an earlier, and potentially more treatable, stage. Many of those tumors are slow growing, but it is difficult to predict which those are.
Eric Small, MD
For an oncologist, this real-time imaging could provide immediate feedback on whether a patient should continue active surveillance of the tumor or pursue treatment, and also whether a therapy is working, either during standard treatment or in a clinical trial.
“There are natural risks in any treatment for prostate cancer, including radiation therapy and surgery. Those risks can have an enormous impact on the patient’s quality of life,” said UCSF oncologist Eric Small, MD, a co-author on the paper, UCSF professor of medicine and urology, and deputy director of the UCSF Helen Diller Family Comprehensive Cancer Center. “This technology begins to give us the ability to more accurately assess the extent and risk of an individual patient’s actual cancer, which is absolutely critical, but so far is largely an unmet medical need.”
Collaboration with GE Healthcare
The technology developed out of a collaboration that began nearly eight years ago, when GE Healthcare approached UCSF to see whether it could translate technology it had developed with researchers in Sweden into a clinical application.
Key Industry Partners for UCSF
UCSF has forged a number of important industry partnerships to help move cutting-edge research more quickly from the laboratory to clinical trials and patient treatments. Here are some of the University's key partners:
- Abbott Diagnostics – Launched in 2008 for viral diagnostics and discovery
- Bayer Healthcare – Launched in 2011 as a master agreement for basic research
- GE Healthcare – Launched in 2005 for prostate and brain tumor diagnosis
- Genentech Inc. (now part of Roche Group) – Launched in 2005 as a master agreement
- Merck-OncoNet – Launched in 2010 for an oncology clinical trials network
- Nikon Instruments, Inc. – Launched in 2006 for the Nikon Imaging Center for basic research
- Pfizer Inc. – Launched in 2010 as a master agreement for basic research
- Sanofi – Launched in 2011 and 2012 for innovative research projects, oncology and diabetes
The hyperpolarizing technology had been shown to detect animal tumors, but converting that for clinical use was a formidable challenge.
UCSF pulled together a team of researchers ranging from oncologists and radiologists to clinical pharmacists with the precise knowledge of building clean-rooms for pharmaceutical production. At the time, Nelson also was the scientific director of the UCSF arm of the California Institute for Quantitative Biosciences (QB3), which supports both basic and translational science at the crossroads of biology and the quantitative sciences, such as imaging and bioinformatics.
“UCSF and QB3 offered an unusual combination of talent all in one location. They brought together the best engineering from UC Berkeley and the best bioscience and pharmacy knowledge from UCSF, and are now demonstrating the technology in a world-renowned academic medical center,” said Jonathan Murray, managing director of Research Circle Technology at GE Healthcare and a co-author on the paper. “At GE Healthcare, we are delighted with the speed of progress of this collaboration. The science is very exciting.”
Success with Prostate Cancer Patients
In the clinical research study, which started in December 2010, the researchers labeled pyruvate with carbon-13 and injected this “hyperpolarized pyruvate” imaging agent into 31 prostate cancer patients in the UCSF Medical Center and UCSF Helen Diller Family Comprehensive Cancer Center. The team then used an MRI to follow pyruvate and its conversion to lactate in the prostate.
In the clinical research study, the hyperpolarized pyruvate imaging agent is con-
verted into lactate at tumor sites and shown in pink on MRI scans of prostate cancer
As in previous studies in mice, the higher, more intense signals indicated a more rapid conversion to lactate, possibly a sign of more aggressive cancer. In contrast, there was very limited conversion detected in normal prostate.
The study deliberately focused on patients with low-grade tumors who had not yet received treatment, to identify the safe and appropriate dosage of pyruvate needed. Future studies will use the technology to assess the effectiveness of a patient’s cancer therapy in shrinking their tumor – knowledge that will enable physicians to assess the dosage of chemotherapy needed on an individual basis.
UCSF and QB3 offered an unusual combination of talent all in one location. They brought together the best engineering from UC Berkeley and the best bioscience and pharmacy knowledge from UCSF, and are now demonstrating the technology in a world-renowned academic medical center.
While potential commercial use is still five to 10 years away, the UCSF team has received grants to extend the technology for studies in patients with cancers of the brain, breast, liver, lymph glands, pancreas and prostate. GE Healthcare also has developed equipment to process the hyperpolarized pyruvate in a less technical environment, enabling a broader clinical trial in the future.
The project was funded through the National Institute of Biomedical Imaging and Bioengineering (NIH grants R01 EB007588 and R21 EB005363). The polarizer and costs of the 13C patient studies were supported with funding from GE Healthcare. Some of the MRI acquisition methods have been patented; the authors declare no other competing interests.
Additional UCSF co-authors on the project include John Kurhanewicz, PhD; Daniel B. Vigneron, PhD; Peder E. Z. Larson, PhD; Andrea L. Harzstark, MD; Marcus Ferrone, PharmD; Mark van Criekinge, MS; Jose W. Chang; Robert Bok, MD, PhD; Ilwoo Park; Galen Reed; Lucas Carvajal; Pamela Munster, MD; and Vivian K. Weinberg, PhD. Additional co-authors include Jan Henrik Ardenkjaer-Larsen, Albert P. Chen, Ralph E. Hurd, Liv-Ingrid Odegardstuen, James Tropp and Jonathan A. Murray from General Electric Healthcare, Waukesha, WI; and Fraser J. Robb, from USA Instruments, Inc., Aurora, OH.
Full results and author contributions can be found in the paper, "Metabolic imaging of patients with prostate cancer using hyperpolarized [1-13C] pyruvate." Sci. Transl. Med. 5, 198ra108 (2013).
These concepts are still investigational and not being offered for sale, nor have they been cleared or approved by the FDA for commercial availability.