Translating Form into Function: Scientists Figure out How an Enzyme Works by Knowing Its Atom-by-Ato

By Wallace Ravven

Brian Shoichet

Update, September, 2007: The Nature research article referenced in this story was the second-most frequently downloaded article from that journal's site during the month of August. In the last 40 years, scientists have perfected ways to determine the knot-like structure of enzymes, but they've been stumped trying to translate the structure into an understanding of function - what the enzyme actually does in the body. This puzzle has hurt drug discovery, since many of the most successful drugs work by blocking enzyme action. Now, in an expedited article in Nature, researchers show that a solution to the puzzle is finally in sight. A team co-led by UCSF's Brian Shoichet, PhD, describes the first success in "decrypting" an enzyme's function from its structure. If their new strategy works with other enzymes, it should become a potent tool to determine how key enzymes work in the body. And since enzyme action is crucial to disease, the technique opens an efficient route to drug discovery, Shoichet says. Shoichet is a UCSF professor of pharmaceutical chemistry and an investigator in the California Institute for Quantitative Biomedical Research, or QB3. The team's success came by modifying a technique called molecular docking, a computer-aided modeling strategy used to search for potential drugs. Docking was pioneered in the UCSF Pharmaceutical Chemistry department in the early 1980s by Irwin Kuntz, PhD. Here's how it works: Researchers first determine the atom-by-atom structure of an enzyme, and then screen many thousands of molecules for one that fits into the empty "active site" of the enzyme. Shoichet calls this a search for the missing piece of a jigsaw puzzle. A molecule that fits the enzyme's active site will block its activity - just what many promising drugs do. The strategy works well for one kind of drug discovery, finding molecules to fit in the active site and physically block enzyme action. But Shoichet's team sought to divine from an enzyme's structure just which natural molecule triggers the enzyme into action - fitting into the active site and enabling the enzyme to act as a catalyst. This was a search for the so-called substrate for the enzyme, a search that has never succeeded simply from knowing an enzyme's configuration. The key to the team's success was a computational feat: simulating candidate substrates that mimicked unstable "intermediate" molecules - those that exist only briefly as the catalyst turns the substrate into a new molecule. Because these intermediates are unstable, scientists have until now been unable to test their fit to the enzyme's active site. Once the scientists had predicted the substrate, team member Frank Raushel, PhD, a professor of chemistry at Texas A&M University, tested the prediction experimentally. The results confirmed the prediction. Steven Almo, PhD, professor of biochemistry at Albert Einstein College of Medicine, further confirmed the finding by determining the substrate's atomic level structure through X-ray crystallography. "To tell the truth, we were very surprised that the docking approach worked to determine the substrate," Shoichet says. "There's so many ways that the approach can go wrong. We're all very gratified." For their experiments, the team extracted an enzyme from a bacterium known as Thermotoga maritima, a microbe that normally lives at very high temperatures and pressures near volcanic ocean vents. Its structure was determined as a part of the structural genomics projects, a large-scale, worldwide effort to determine the structures of enzymes and receptors. With the nature of the substrate in hand, the scientists went on to discover that the enzyme works in a previously uncharacterized metabolic pathway in bacteria. The research was published on Sunday, July 1, in the advance online edition of Nature. It will later appear in the print edition. Lead author of the Nature paper is Johannes Hermann, PhD, a former postdoctoral student in Shoichet's lab. Co-authors, along with Shoichet, Raushel and Almo, are Ricardo Marti-Arbona, a graduate student at Texas A&M, and Alexander Fedorov, PhD, and Elena Fedorov, both staff scientists in biochemistry at Albert Einstein College of Medicine. The research is supported in part by the National Institute of General Medical Sciences, one of the National Institutes of Health. UCSF is a leading university that advances health worldwide by conducting advanced biomedical research, educating graduate students in the life sciences and health professions, and providing complex patient care.
Structure-Based Activity Prediction for an Enzyme of Unknown Function Johannes C. Hermann, Ricardo Marti-Arbona, Alexander A. Fedorov, Elena Fedorov, Steven C. Almo, Brian K. Shoichet, Frank M. Raushel Nature, advanced online publication July 1, 2007 Abstract | Full Text | Full Text (PDF)
Related Links: Shoichet Lab